Yazarlar
Abstract
The increasing integration of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) into educational processes requires teachers to reconsider how they make pedagogical decisions, enact their professional roles, and draw upon their expertise. While existing research has largely focused on AI use frequency, perceived benefits, limitations, and attitudes, less attention has been paid to how teachers evaluate AI-generated suggestions in relation to their own pedagogical knowledge and professional judgment.
This study examined primary school teachers’ interactions with GenAI in the context of pedagogical reasoning, professional autonomy, and teacher expertise. The study employed a qualitative research approach and an interpretive phenomenological design, involving 18 primary school teachers with varying levels of professional experience. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews and analyzed using reflexive thematic analysis. The findings indicated that teachers positioned GenAI not merely as an information-providing technology but as a “digital colleague” that could support pedagogical decision-making while requiring critical evaluation. Five themes emerged: the tension between efficiency and pedagogical accuracy, conditional trust in AI, the teacher as the final decision-maker, filtering AI-generated outputs through pedagogical judgment, and the redefinition of teacher expertise. The findings showed that teachers primarily used GenAI for lesson planning, activity development, differentiated instruction, and material preparation. However, AI-generated outputs were not adopted uncritically; instead, they were evaluated and adapted according to students’ characteristics, classroom context, learning objectives, and teachers’ professional experiences. The results further demonstrated that GenAI use did not diminish the teacher’s role but rather made the teacher’s position as an expert who selects, questions, adapts, and assumes pedagogical responsibility more visible. Overall, the study suggests that the relationship between AI and teaching extends beyond technology use and represents an ongoing negotiation among trust, critical reasoning, and professional autonomy.
Keywords: Generative artificial intelligence, primary school teachers, pedagogical reasoning, teacher autonomy, teacher expertise, AI-supported teaching
Kaynak gösterimi
Özhan, U., & Akkaya, S. (2026). Trusting the machine, remaining the teacher: Primary teachers’ pedagogical reasoning in the age of generative ai. In Abstract Proceedings. XII. Uluslararası TURKCESS Eğitim ve Sosyal Bilimler Kongresi.

