Yazarlar
Abstract
Two major curricular traditions dominate Western educational thought. Among them, the Didaktik tradition is distinguished from the Anglo-American model by the greater pedagogical autonomy it grants to teachers in the teaching and learning process. However, this distinction is predominantly rooted in philosophical and historical discourse, and empirical evidence supporting such a differentiation remains scarce. Addressing this gap, the present study aims to empirically investigate the Didaktik tradition through the case of Norway. Drawing on data from PISA 2022, the study explores the relationship between teacher autonomy and students’ science literacy. Teacher autonomy is operationalized in terms of assessment practices, including the use of mandatory standardized tests, non-mandatory standardized tests, teacher-developed tests, and teachers’ judgmental ratings. Given the hierarchical structure of the data, Hierarchical Linear Modeling (HLM) was employed for analysis. The dependent variable is science literacy, analyzed through ten plausible values. At Level 1, student-level variables include socioeconomic status (SES), gender, and immigrant background. At Level 2, school-level variables related to assessment practices were included. The final model includes a random intercept across schools, while all slopes are fixed. Findings indicate that all Level 1 variables are significantly associated with science literacy. Higher SES is linked to higher performance, while girls outperform boys, and native students score higher than their immigrant peers. At the school level, no significant relationship was found between assessment-related indicators of teacher autonomy and science literacy. However, the near-significant result for non-mandatory standardized test usage (p = .07) suggests potential patterns warranting further investigation. Overall, the findings reveal limited evidence supporting the hypothesis that teacher autonomy in assessment is associated with science achievement. Conversely, the strong predictive power of student-level characteristics highlights the enduring impact of socioeconomic and demographic factors. These results underscore the critical role of equitable learning conditions in improving educational outcomes.
Keywords: Assessment Practices, Hierarchical Linear Modeling, PISA 2022, Science Literacy, Teacher Autonomy.
Kaynak gösterimi
Kocabaş, H. U., & Cırık, İ. (2025). A multilevel investigation of assessment autonomy and science literacy: Evidence from norway. In Abstract Proceedings. XI. Uluslararası TURKCESS Eğitim ve Sosyal Bilimler Kongresi.

