Yazarlar
Abstract
Problem Durumu: Studies on Beş Sevim Apartmanı were examined and it was determined that some of the studies were related to postmodern and folk culture elements in the novel, and others were related to concepts such as gender and alienation.
In this study, unlike others, it is aimed to reach comprehensive conclusions on the possible consequences of Freud's civilization-subject relationship by focusing on it. In this study, based on Freud's book titled Civilization and Its Discontents, the relationships of the characters in Beş Sevim Apartmanı (2003) with their lost objects and the tragic consequences of these relationships are questioned. Araştırma Yöntemi: The study will seek answers to the following questions using Freudian theory: Is the relationship between civilization and the individual natural, or is there a relationship between the two based on necessity/tyranny, where one tries to dominate the other? What is hidden behind these relationships that cause the individual to "go crazy" and how are they revealed in the text? Finally, what defense methods does the individual use to ensure the continuity of life? In the novel, which consists of five frame stories that are different in content but similar in structure and function, each character's problematic and traumatic relationship with external reality stands out. The lost object of the characters is their mother or father. Characters who cannot establish healthy relationships with their families cannot adapt to the outside world, commit crimes and take refuge in fairy tales/fictional texts to compensate for their crimes. Therefore, there are two different frame stories for each character in the book, one "real" and the other "fictional". Object loss and inability to hold on to external reality first cause trauma-induced insanity in the characters. As a result, the character exhibits instinctive behavior and becomes aggressive. With the remorse he feels afterwards, he tries to resolve this crime with a fantastic story that has healing/therapeutic properties. This typical structure is the same throughout the text. An attempt is made to capture the holistic subject image that cannot be achieved in external reality in fairy tales. Based on this thematic unity of the text, the "aggression" impulses and "guilt" psychology that emerged after the "civilization-subject" and "object-subject" relationships in the stories of Oğuz, Yusuf and Melike were examined in the context of Freudian psychoanalytic theory, and comprehensive conclusions were tried to be reached about them. Beklenen Sonuçlar: Accordingly, the characters turn to their instincts by suspending social norms. Civilization's efforts to discourage these primitive emotions remain fruitless. It causes dissatisfaction in the family, which is the smallest and basic unit of civilization, and as a result, the impulse of aggression emerges. Melike grows up without a father. He knew that his father was "one of the hundreds of men" who came into his mother's life, so he blames his mother for what he went through and kills her. Oğuz does not know his father at all, and Yusuf's mother is indifferent towards him and his father is a workaholic. The characters of the novel, who cannot find what they hope for in the outside world or objects belonging to the outside world, turn to the primordial and natural, and therefore to their impulses, with this dissatisfaction. Mothers are blamed and killed for not providing sufficient satisfaction. The idea of creating unity among individuals in the process of civilization fails. Cultural codes that represent civilization, such as family, move away from this idea of unity because they cannot receive the necessary support from civilization or acquire new objects. Therefore, the "cleft" between the external world and the subject causes a return to the primal/instinctive in Oğuz, Melike and Yusuf. The pleasure principle, which is repressed and threatened with pain in Oğuz, Yusuf and Melike, who cannot establish unity with their parents, emerges as a strong aggressive impulse. This "crime" is compensated with stories about demons and fairies. While the characters in the story do not change, the content changes, and the healing power of the fictional text is evident. This can also be interpreted as the disguise of uncanny themes of "reality". Childhood memories and feelings for the "parent" reveal the cognitive processes that trigger them. In fairy tales, Yusuf, Oğuz and Melike strive to find their lost homes/parents and get rid of the feeling of "guilt" and present "another text". People who search for their home in the fairytale world and resort to distorted memories to find it renew the image of the "missing parent". Kaynakça: Freud, S. (2018). Grup Psikolojisi ve Ego Analizi. In S. Budak (Trans.), Uygarlık, Din ve Toplum (6th ed., pp. 101-187). İstanbul: Öteki. Freud, S. (2018). Savaş ve Ölüm Üzerine Düşünceler. In S. Budak (Trans.), Uygarlık, Din ve Toplum (6th ed., pp. 65-101). İstanbul: Öteki. Freud, S. (2018). Uygarlık ve Hoşnutsuzlukları. In S. Budak (Trans.), Uygarlık, Din ve Toplum (6th ed., pp. 251-351). İstanbul: Öteki. Freud, S. (2018). Uygar Cinsel Ahlak ve Çağdaş Nevroz Hastalığı. In S. Budak (Trans.), Uygarlık, Din ve Toplum (6th ed., pp. 33-65). İstanbul: Öteki. Freud, S. (2021). Kültürdeki Huzursuzluk. V. Atayman (Trans.). (4th ed.). İstanbul: Say Yayınları. Freud, S. (2022). Bilinç Dışı. E. Çalıner (Trans.). (5th ed.). İstanbul: Olimpos Yayınları. Freud, S. (2022). Totem ve Tabu: Vahşiler ve Nevrotiklerin Ruhsal Yaşamlarındaki Bazı Örtüşmeler. Z. A. Yılmazer (Trans.). (4th ed.). İstanbul: Olimpos Yayınları. Jung, C. G. (2021). Ruh: İnsan, Sanat, Edebiyat. İ. H. Yılmaz (Trans.). (4th ed.). İstanbul: Pinhan Yayıncılık. Lorenzer, A., & Görlich, B. (2021). Giriş. In V. Atayman (Trans.), Kültürdeki Huzursuzluk (4th ed., pp. 33-62). İstanbul: Say Yayınları. Söğüt, M. (2022). Beş Sevim Apartmanı. İstanbul: Can Yayınları. Strachey, J. (2021). Sigmund Freud: Hayatı ve Düşüncelerinin Bir Özeti. A. E. Polat (Trans.). In Kültürdeki Huzursuzluk (4th ed., pp. 7-21). İstanbul: Say Yayınları.
Keywords: Beş Sevim Apartmanı, Sigmund Freud, lost object, aggression, guilt, substitute satisfactions.
Kaynak gösterimi
Sağıroğlu, B. (2024). Cıvılızatıon and ıts dıscontents: Beş sevim apartmanı. Tam Bildiri Kitabı içinde. X. Uluslararası TURKCESS Eğitim ve Sosyal Bilimler Kongresi.

